Everton 4 Liverpool 4: One of the greatest Merseyside derbies ever played

Matthew Crist looks back on one of the most enthralling Merseyside derbies ever as Everton and Liverpool shared eight goals in an FA Cup classic from 1991...
Matthew Crist  |  4th January 2020

When Everton and Liverpool faced each other in an FA Cup fifth-round replay at Goodison Park on February 20th, 1991, it produced one of the most memorable Merseyside derbies in decades, a game which is still considered one of the greatest derbies ever.

The two had played their first tie just three days earlier at Anfield as the Red and Blue of Merseyside canceled each other out in a largely forgettable 0-0 draw, but this was to be just the appetizer for the main course which was to follow.

Liverpool, under the guidance of manager Kenny Dalglish, were three points clear at the top of Division One and looked on course to retain the title which they had won comfortably the previous season.

Everton, however, were struggling under Kendall, after a turgid start to the season had seen them go seven games without a win. They still boasted some top talent in their ranks, however, in the form of Neville Southall, Graeme Sharp and record signing Tony Cottee.

In front of a crowd of 37, 766, the tie had all the ingredients for a classic encounter under the Goodison Park lights and certainly didn’t disappoint.

Liverpool took the lead when Ian Rush cut inside and shot past Neville Southall, only for the ball to be acrobatically cleared off the line before falling to Peter Beardsley, who fired the Reds ahead.

But two minutes into the second half and the tie was level when Andy Hinchcliffe crossed from the left and an unmarked Sharp timed his leap perfectly to nod the ball past Grobbelaar.


The momentum shifted with just20 minutes to go when  Peter Beardsley received a short pass and skipped over a challenge, before shimmying away from another blue shirt and firing a superb left-footed shot past Southall.

Just a minute later, and with Liverpool’s fans still celebrating, a long ball upfield caused chaos in the Liverpool defence as Steve Nicol confused his own ‘keeper, Grobbelaar, and Sharp prodded the ball into the net.

Just five minutes later and Liverpool are ahead once again when Molby perfectly finds Ian Rush for the easiest of headers past a stranded Southall and Liverpool appear to have the game in the bag.

But in the dying seconds, Tony Cottee, who had come on as a late substitiute,  pounced on a hopeful flick and with Liverpool’s defenders stood watching, prodded the ball past Grobbelaar with his left foot.

In extra-time Liverpool made it 4-3 with the goal of the game when John Barnes cut in from the left touchline then, from the edge of the penalty area, curled a dipping, right foot shot into the far corner of the net to surely win it.

All is not lost for Everton though and, thanks to some more calamitous defending on the edge of the Liverpool box, Cottee, once again seizes his opportunity and fires the ball under Grobbelaar to make things all square at 4-4 as Goodison Park erupted.

The following week, with Ronnie Moran in caretaker control of Liverpool following the shock resignation of Kenny Dalglish, a Dave Watson strike was enough for Everton to win the second replay, back at Goodison, 1-0 and finally settle this epic encounter; but what had gone before would be remembered for years to come.

“Merseyside derbies should come with a Government health warning,” wrote the Liverpool ECHO’s Ric George as he opened his report on one of the most enthralling games ever played between the two sides. “This was without question the greatest match I have ever watched – but also the most stressful.”

Everton v Liverpool
FA Cup Third Round
Sunday, January 5th
16:01 kick-off


Leave a comment

Follow Matthew Crist on Twitter @Matthewjcrist
Share this article:     


Trending Now

TV Times: Bumper weekend of live FA Cup games awaits armchair fansTV Times: Bumper weekend of live FA Cup games awaits armchair fans 23rd January 2020 No fewer than eight FA Cup fourth round ties have…
4 midfielders Barcelona are targeting4 midfielders Barcelona are targeting 31st July 2018 Despite claiming a 25th La Liga title, losing just once…
NFL Week 17: Who's in and who's out of the playoff picture?NFL Week 17: Who’s in and who’s out of the playoff picture? 28th December 2019 A number of teams have booked their spot in the…

Follow Us

Latest Tweets

16 ties will take place between Friday 24th and Monday 27th January with half of those being broadcast on television as the BBC and BT Sport share the coverage #FACup coverage between them.

🏆 Farmers Insurance Open
⛳ Tiger Woods or Rory McIlroy to win
😃 NOW 4.75*
👉 https://t.co/HdVijFEUJQ

🔥 After 1 winner at Southwell this afternoon Jockey Ben Curtis now goes looking for more success at Newcastle this evening.

🏇 B A Curtis To Ride 2 Or More Winners Today at Newcastle
✔️ NOW 2.40*
👉 https://t.co/Q1evzVZBK0
📄 T&Cs: https://t.co/RIWTbljU8f

Load More...

Brand Ambassadors

Paul Robinson

Former England, Leeds United, Spurs, Blackburn Rovers and Burnley goalkeeper.

Amy Murphy

Dual-purpose racehorse trainer based in Newmarket.

Brian McClair

Former Manchester United, Celtic and Scotland forward
* Odds subject to change. Maximum bet regulations may apply. Terms & conditions apply. 18+. Gambling can be addictive. Please bet responsibly.